Sir Hartley Shawcross, British Prosecutor at the Nuremberg War Crimes Trial in Germany after World War II. Shawcross is remembered for saying, "There comes a point when a man must refuse to answer to his leader if he is also to answer to his own conscience." Photo credit: Photolibrarian, Creative Commons 2.0.
Introduction
This page highlights the power and discretion given to prosecutors in the U.S. legal system.
General Resources on Prosecutors
Real Justice PAC (website) co-led by Shaun King to campaign for progressive prosecutors; see Shaun King, The Real Justice PAC, and Daniel Marans, Black Activist Starts Group That Aims To Elect Progressive Prosecutors (Huffington Post, Feb 15, 2018)
Drug War Facts (website)
Trail of Silence (website) tracking police killings of unarmed civilians from yr 2000
American Civil Liberties Union, Private Prisons (ACLU website)
Marc Mauer, et.al., The Meaning of "Life": Long Prison Sentences in Context. The Sentencing Project, May 2004.
Frontline, Erma Faye Stewart and Regina Kelly in Hearne, Texas. PBS WGBH, Jun 17, 2004.
Michael King and US Probation Department, Mandatory Sentence. Michael King, Aug 11, 2007. And part 2 a short youtube video filmed in Boston for educational purposes.
Joshua Correll, et.al., Across the Thin Blue Line: Police Officers and Racial Bias in the Decision to Shoot. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2007.
Vicky Peleaz, The Prison Industry in the United States: Big Business or a New Form of Slavery? Global Research, Mar 10, 2008.
Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. The New Press | Amazon page, Jan 2010. See also Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow. Children Defense Fund, Dec 15, 2010. A 20 min interview.
Brennan Center for Justice, Racial Disparities in Federal Prosecutions. Brennan Center for Justice at NYU, Mar 2010.
Noam Chomsky and Glenn Greenwald, How the Law is Used to Destroy Equality and Protect the Powerful. CSpan video, Oct 29, 2011.
Maia Szalavitz, Study: Whites More Likely to Abuse Drugs Than Blacks. Time, Nov 7, 2011.
Annie E. Casey Foundation, The Case for Reducing Juvenile Incarceration: No Place for Kids. Annie E. Casey Foundation, 2011.
Michelle Alexander, Go to Jail: Crash the Justice System. New York Times, Mar 10, 2012.
Michael Kelly, 13 Signs that America's Prison System is Out of Control. Business Insider, Apr 12, 2012.
The House I Live In (2013), documentary arguing that the U.S. War on Drugs has failed
Bobby Constantino, I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look into the Justice System. The Atlantic, Dec 17, 2013.
Paul Martin, Money-Driven Criminal Justice System Drives Poverty, Crime Rate. The Durham News, Feb 14, 2014.
Matt Taibbi, Who Goes to Jail? The American Justice Gap from Wall Street to Main Street. Democracy Now, Apr 15, 2014.
Carol Rose, Independent Report Confirms Racially Disparate Treatment in Boston. ACLU, Jul 4, 2014.
Martha Minow, We Must Ensure Everyone Has Access to Equal Justice. Boston Globe, Oct 23, 2014.
Judd Legum, Justice Scalia Explains What Was Wrong With The Ferguson Grand Jury. Think Progress, Nov 26, 2014.
Thabiti Anyabwile, Why I Believe the Grand Jury Got it Wrong and Injustice Triumphed. Gospel Coalition, Nov 26, 2014.
Ta-Nehisi Coates, Barack Obama, Ferguson, and the Evidence of Things Unsaid. The Altantic, Nov 26, 2014.
Michelle Alexander, White Privilege and the War on Drugs. Atlanta Black Star, Dec 2, 2014.
Evan Horowitz, If Crime is Falling, Why Aren't Prisons Shrinking. Boston Globe, Jan 15, 2015.
Adam Liptak, Why Judges Tilt to the Right. New York Times, Jan 31, 2015.
Sue Bell Cobb, I Was Alabama's Top Judge. I'm Ashamed by What I Had to Do to Get There. Politico, Mar/Apr 2015.
Alec Karakatsanis, Policing, Mass Imprisonment, and the Failure of America's Lawyers. Harvard Law Review, Apr 10, 2015.
Dahlia Lithwick, Pseudoscience in the Witness Box: The FBI Faked an Entire Field of Forensic Science. Slate, Apr 22, 2015.
Marquaysa Battle, 12 Heartbreaking Facts About The School To Prison Pipeline That Every Person Should Know. TeaBreakfast, May 15, 2015.
John F. Pfaff, The War on Drugs and Prison Growth: Limited Importance, Limited Legislative Options. Harvard Journal of Legislation, Jun 2015. Critiques Alexander but agrees on pragmatic grounds that change would be helpful; highlights the prosecutor role.
Bill Quigley, 40 Reasons Why Our Jails Are Full of Black and Brown People. Huffington Post, Jun 2, 2015.
John Oliver, Bail. Last Week Tonight, Jun 7, 2015.
Ta-Nehisi Coates, The Brief and Tragic Life of Kalief Browder. The Atlantic, Jun 8, 2015.
Aviva Shen, Justice Scalia Just Took An Important Swing At Mandatory Minimums. Think Progress, Jun 26, 2015.
Jon Basil Utley, Why We Need Criminal Justice Reform. The American Conservative, Jul 8, 2015.
Leon Neyfahk, Prosecution is About Locking Black People Up. Salon, Jul 10, 2015.
George Yancy and Joe Feagin, American Racism in the "White Frame". New York Times, Jul 27, 2015.
Jason Riley, Louisville Judge Questioned for Dismissing Juries Based on Lack of Minorities. WDRB News, Oct 20, 2015.
Leon Neyfakh, Top Police and Prosecutors Condemn Mass Incarceration. Salon, Oct 23, 2015.
Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve, Commentary: Anita's Army: Rank and File Racism in the Power to Prosecute. NBC News, Nov 27, 2015. re: Chicago, LaQuan McDonald
Conor Friedersdorf, The Corrupt System That Killed LaQuan McDonald. The Atlantic, Nov 27, 2015.
Abby Haglage, When White Girls Deal Drugs, They Walk. Daily Beast, Dec 1, 2015.
Editorial Staff, A Blow To White Supremacy As California Becomes First State To Ban Grand Juries In Police Shooting Cases. AfricanGlobe, Dec 1, 2015.
Jon Swaine, Oliver Laughland, Jamiles Lartey and Ciara McCarthy, Ties That Bind. The Guardian UK, Dec 31, 2015. District attorneys who clear police officers of killing
Vikki Tobak, Adam Foss Has A Vision For Juvenile Justice Reform. Fader, Apr/May 2016. Regarding cultural competency for prosecutors.
Lara Bazelon, Pennsylvania's Shame. Slate, Oct 12, 2016. ill-trained police, underpaid defense attorneys, wrongful convictions
Eli Hager and Bill Keller, Everything You Think You Know About Mass Incarceration Is Wrong. The Marshall Project, Feb 9, 2017. A very helpful analysis of violent vs. non-violent crime, federal vs. state prison populations, and the role of the prosecutor.
Stephen Carter, 21,000 Reasons Scalia Was Right. Bloomberg, Apr 21, 2017. On the Sixth Amendment, and the MA case of forged and tampered drug testing
Sari Horwitz and Matt Zapotosky, Sessions Issues Sweeping New Criminal Charging Policy. Washington Post, May 12, 2017.
Thor Benson, Black Lives Matter Just Scored a Massive Victory. Attn, May 17, 2017.
Beth Baumann, Senators from the Right and the Left Come Together for Criminal Justice Reform. The Blaze, Jul 27, 2017.
Emily Yoffe, Innocence Is Irrelevant. The Atlantic, Sep 2017. The plea bargain—and the millions of Americans who are suffering the consequences
German Lopez, If You Care About Ending Mass Incarceration, Look at What Philadelphia Just Did (Vox, Nov 8, 2017. a local prosecutor's race just set the standard in the fight against mass incarceration
Matt Ferner, George Soros, Progressive Groups To Spend Millions To Elect Reformist Prosecutors (Huffington Post, May 12, 2018.
Public Citizen, Penalties for Corporate Violations Plummet by Double Digits Under Trump. Public Citizen, Jul 25, 2018. and full report by Rick Claypool, Taylor Lincoln, Michael Tanglis and Alan Zibel, Corporate Impunity: “Tough on Crime” Trump Is Weak on Corporate Crime and Wrongdoing. Public Citizen, Jul 2018. and summary by Rick Claypool, ‘Law and Order’ Trump Is Soft on Corporate Crime and Wrongdoing. Corporate Presidency, Jul 2018.
Matt Apuzzo, What Will Mueller Do? The Answer Might Lie in a By-the-Book Past. New York Times, Aug 25, 2018.
Vox, The Big Problem with How We Pick Juries. Vox, Oct 12, 2018. A legal loophole lets juries be less diverse.
Jeremy Diamond and Alex Rogers, The Bill That Wouldn't Die: The Unlikely Story Behind the Criminal Justice Overhaul. CNN, Dec 18, 2018. Remarkable story of the political maneuverings; a hopeful sign that alliances can be built across the political aisle on this issue.
Jackie Kucinich, Kamala Harris’ A.G. Office Tried to Keep Inmates Locked Up for Cheap Labor. The Daily Beast, Feb 11, 2019. "Lawyers for California also argued that allowing certain inmates to be paroled early would deplete a program that allowed prisons to fight wildfires"
Ricardo Garcia, A 1963 Supreme Court Decision Transformed the U.S. Justice System. Now It's Threatened. Los Angeles Times, Mar 18, 2019. defendants entitled to public defense
Emily Bazelon, Charged: The New Movement to Transform American Prosecution and End Mass Incarceration. Random House | Amazon page, Apr 9, 2019.
Kira Lerner, Courts Are Intervening to Dismantle Unjust Cash Bail Systems Across the U.S. The Appeal, Sep 26, 2019. “A series of victories for advocates reflects a shift in the ‘popular narrative’ around bail.”
Adrian Tirtanadi, Creating Universal Access to Justice. Passion Talks International, Nov 23, 2019. Lack of access to legal assistance is a major driver of poverty. Meaning we have decent laws and decent supports, but lack law enforcement in civil suits for people in poverty. One legal aid attorney reduces property crime by 8x as one police officer. Legal aid is the only factor known to reduce domestic violence. Legal aid has about the same effect as affordable housing resources in reducing homelessness.
Evan Sernoffsky, San Francisco DA Chesa Boudin Ends Cash Bail for All Criminal Cases. San Francisco Chronicle, Jan 22, 2020. “Human Rights Watch, a nonprofit network of journalists, attorneys and policy experts that reports on abuses, has published studies that found the pretrial release of defendants who pose no threat to public safety did not result in increased crimes or more missed court dates.”
The Young Turks, District Attorney: No Injuries To Elijah McClain. The Young Turks, Jun 26, 2020. highlights both the police and the prosecutor’s negligence.
Michael German, Hidden in Plain Sight: Racism, White Supremacy, and Far-Right Militancy in Law Enforcement. Brennan Center for Justice, Aug 27, 2020. “The government’s response to known connections of law enforcement officers to violent racist and militant groups has been strikingly insufficient.”
Janelle Griffith and Laura Strickler, Breonna Taylor's Ex Was Offered a Plea Deal to Say She Was Part of an ‘Organized Crime Syndicate’. NBC News, Sep 2, 2020. “The news of the plea offer raised the question of whether law enforcement officials were attempting to provide an incentive to Jamarcus Glover to help justify the raid that resulted in Breonna Taylor’s death.”
Kristine Phillips, Police Misconduct, Such as Falsifying Evidence, is a Leading Cause of Wrongful Convictions, Study Finds. USA Today, Sep 15, 2020. “according to a study released Tuesday by the National Registry of Exonerations that focused on the role police and prosecutors play in false convictions in the U.S. Researchers studied 2,400 convictions of defendants who were later found innocent over a 30-year period and found that 35% of these cases involved some type of misconduct by police. More than half – 54% – involved misconduct by police or prosecutors.”
Anna Kasparian, Grand Jurors in Breonna Taylor Case: The Attorney General Lied. The Young Turks, Oct 30, 2020.
Tim Stelloh, Los Angeles' New District Attorney Announces Sweeping Reforms on First Day. NBC News, Dec 7, 2020. “The reforms are aimed at "permanently" changing the course of the criminal justice system in California and beyond, he said.” New LA DA George Gascon, who was elected as a reformer.
Chris Gelardi, Detroit is Suing Black Lives Matter Protesters for “Civil Conspiracy”. The Intercept, Dec 21, 2020.
Matthew Martens on Twitter (Twitter, Jul 23, 2021) provides stats and rationales for why prosecutors jail people prior to court, and why this incentivizes people to give guilty pleas. “94% of criminal convictions in state court are the result of guilty pleas. It’s 97% in federal court.”
Amber Ruffin, If Prosecutors Represent America, Why Are 95% of Them White? The Amber Ruffin Show, Mar 4, 2022. Ruffin starts with the Ahmad Arbury case, and his three murderers, and their connection with the prosecutor’s office.
Bill Rankin, Former Glynn County DA, Greg McMichael Exchanged Phone Calls After Ahmaud Arbery Killing, Motion Says. Atlanta Journal-Constitution, May 5, 2022. Re: Jackie Johnson, the former district attorney of the Brunswick Judicial Circuit.
Mehdi Hasan, San Francisco Kicked Out Its Progressive DA...and Violent Crime Went Up. The Mehdi Hasan Show | MSNBC, Aug 17, 2023.
Hedwig Lee, How Does Structural Racism Operate (in) the Contemporary US Criminal Justice System? Duke University Scholars, Annual Review of Criminology, Jan 26, 2024. See quotes by Augustus Corbett, MAGA, You're Lying! Black Men Are The Victims Of The Criminal Justice System, Not Trump. Defiant Lawyers Network, Jun 6, 2024.
Christian Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: Topics:
This section on Criminal Justice highlights the biblical, church historical, and practical importance of Christian restorative justice. We examine Restorative Justice in its Christian and secular forms, as well as efforts to apply Classroom Restorative Justice to address the school-to-prison pipeline. We also maintain awareness of Human Trafficking and Drug Policy because of the moral and political importance of these policies. Crime Stats highlights the facts and political uses of statistics. Police Oversight tracks proposed and implemented forms of public governance over the police. Policing lists resources on the police abuse of the public trust. Prosecutors lists resources on the role of prosecutors in the legal system and the discretion they have. Sentencing & Prisons highlight moral problems with jury selection, sentencing disparities, prison conditions, conduct in the correctional systems, and the political placement and funding of prisons to benefit mostly white districts. Prison Labor highlights patterns, statistics, and stories. Reintegration examines the moral imperative of assisting returning citizens.
Related pages include: Race and Criminal Justice for how racism has impacted criminal justice historically in the U.S.; Race and Slavery for an examination of the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade; Sex Industry for attempts at legalizing aspects of the sex trade.